For years, calling José Ramírez “underrated” felt almost like a badge of honor.
It was a way for fans to signal that they were paying closer attention than everyone else.
That they understood the numbers behind the noise. That they saw greatness hiding in plain sight while louder stars took the spotlight.
That era might finally be over.
On Wednesday night, MLB Network did something it had never done so definitively—it removed the ambiguity.
José Ramírez was ranked the No. 1 third baseman in baseball, not by debate, not by reputation, but by a margin analysts openly admitted was unusually wide.
Not just first. Clearly first.
The list itself was stacked: Max Muncy, Alex Bregman, Matt Chapman, Manny Machado—names that usually dominate conversations at the position.
And yet, when former third baseman Mike Lowell described the ranking, the tone wasn’t competitive.
It was declarative.
“There’s nothing he doesn’t do great,” Lowell said.
And then came the line that quietly reframed everything: there may not have been another position ranking where the gap between No.1 and No.2 felt this large.
That’s not praise. That’s separation.
Ramírez’s résumé already reads like a Hall of Fame outline—seven All-Star selections, six Silver Sluggers, perennial MVP votes.
But what’s striking now is how little resistance there was to putting him on top. No heated panels. No split opinions. Just consensus.
In 2025, he hit .283 with 30 home runs, 34 doubles, 85 RBIs, and stole 44 bases. Another 30–30 season. Again. At 33. While playing elite defense. While running the bases like someone ten years younger.
And yet, the most telling part of this moment isn’t the ranking itself.
It’s how long it took.
Ramírez doesn’t look like the prototype. He isn’t towering. He doesn’t dominate highlight reels with raw size. His excellence is compact, relentless, almost routine.
The kind that doesn’t demand attention—but keeps winning anyway.
That may be why the “underrated” label stuck for so long. He didn’t need marketing. He didn’t need theatrics. He just kept closing seasons with numbers that quietly dared people to argue otherwise.
Now, after signing a seven-year, $175 million extension with Cleveland and leading the Guardians to their third AL Central title in four years, the league finally seems willing to say what it’s been circling for nearly a decade.
José Ramírez isn’t just one of the best.
He’s the standard.
MLB Network recently ranked him fifth overall among the top 100 players entering 2026—behind names like Ohtani and Judge—but even that feels like a separate conversation.
At third base, the debate appears finished.
What’s left is a subtler question.
If this gap has truly existed all along, why did it take so long for it to be acknowledged? And what else about Ramírez’s career have we normalized simply because excellence arrived without noise?
Because now that the crown is official, the silence around his dominance feels louder than ever.
And it leaves an uncomfortable thought lingering: was José Ramírez ever underrated—or did the rest of baseball just take too long to catch up?
Leave a Reply