Harrison Bader is gone, and Phillies fans are melting down.
Texas Rangers v Cleveland Guardians | Diamond Images/GettyImages
Earlier this week, former Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Harrison Bader reportedly agreed to a two-year, $20.5 million contract with the San Francisco Giants, ending any realistic chance of a reunion in 2026.
Bader was a fan favorite during his short time in Philly, especially after a strong second-half stretch that made him look like exactly the kind of energetic, defense-first outfielder this roster needs.
So naturally, the second Bader came off the board, part of the fanbase turned its frustration toward the man the Phillies did sign: Adolis García.
And now the comparisons are getting out of control.
The García vs. Bader debate is turning into a fan overreaction
On social media, one post from SleeperPhillies went viral for slamming the Phillies’ decision-making and framing Bader as a clearly superior player.
“Adolis Garcia is NOT the same player Harrison Bader is. How much did Dave Dombrowski give Garcia? The same as Bader… That’s the reason this team won’t win,” the post read.
The frustration is understandable. Bader was good in Philly. García hasn’t been at his best lately. And yes — Bader was the better player in 2025.
But that doesn’t mean the gap between them is as massive as fans are pretending.
It also doesn’t mean choosing Bader would’ve magically fixed the outfield.
If the Phillies signed Bader instead… the outfield would still be shaky
Here’s the part some fans are skipping over:
Even if Philadelphia brought Bader back, the Phillies would still be staring at the same core issue — right field instability, especially with the team still expected to move on from Nick Castellanos before Opening Day.
Would Bader have played right field full-time?
He can, but he’s spent most of his career in center field, where his glove plays best.
Bader would’ve improved depth, sure. But the Phillies’ outfield questions wouldn’t disappear just because he returned.
And realistically, the Phillies could’ve signed both players if they wanted to: García and Bader would have created a stronger veteran safety net. Instead, it became an either-or situation, and now fans are acting like one choice was genius and the other was unforgivable.
That’s not how roster building works.
Bader is a great fit… but he’s not the offensive threat fans think he is
Bader had a strong 2025, and his Phillies stint was especially impressive.
After arriving at the trade deadline, Bader posted a .305/.361/.463 slash line with an .824 OPS in 50 games with Philadelphia. That kind of production stood out in a lineup that often struggled to find consistent outfield offense.
Before that, with the Minnesota Twins, Bader hit .258/.339/.439 with a .778 OPS in 96 games, along with 12 home runs and 38 RBIs.
Overall, his 2025 numbers looked like the breakout Phillies fans wanted to believe in:
.277/.347/.449 with a .796 OPS.
But here’s the reality check:
Bader’s career numbers are much closer to average than star-level. He’s a career .247 hitter with a .714 OPS, and he isn’t a consistent power bat. Even his career-high 17 home runs in 2025 is more of an outlier than something you can bank on every year.
García has flaws… but he has something Bader doesn’t
Adolis García is not a perfect player. He strikes out more. He can run hot-and-cold. And he’s coming off two rough seasons offensively.
But García has something that makes him a completely different type of gamble:
Real power upside.
In 2025, García hit 19 home runs, which isn’t special — but it’s not nothing either. And Phillies fans conveniently forget that García hit 39 home runs in 2023, proving he has game-changing pop when he’s right.
Yes, his overall career OPS sits at .730, and that number is dragged down heavily by his .675 OPS combined across 2024 and 2025.
But if García rebounds even halfway back to his peak, he gives Philadelphia something Bader never has:
A legitimate middle-of-the-order threat.
Bottom line: the Bader love is real — but the García hate is premature
Phillies fans don’t have to pretend García is better than Bader.
But acting like signing García instead of Bader is “why this team won’t win” is a complete loss of perspective.
The Phillies didn’t lose their World Series chances because they chose one veteran outfielder over another.
And if García finds his rhythm again in 2026, this entire argument is going to disappear overnight — the same way it always does when the results start speaking louder than the tweets.
Leave a Reply