Some contracts aren’t about creating a buzz. They exist because of memories, because of the belief that “we did this before.” The Milwaukee Brewers’ reunion with Peter Strzelecki on a minor league contract is exactly that.
In 2018, Strzelecki arrived in Milwaukee without a title, without a draft, just a free agent overlooked from the University of South Florida. Four years later, he unexpectedly became one of the Brewers’ most consistent relievers — in a season fans would rather forget.
After a shaky debut in early June 2022, Strzelecki was moved up and down, and finally…stayed. And while he stayed, the Milwaukee bullpen gained something rare at the time: reliability. August ERA of 3.24. September ERA of 2.57. Finishing the season with an ERA of 2.83 — a more than convincing MLB introduction for a pitcher nobody expected much from.
Then things went downhill.
The 2023 season lacked that sharpness. While the pitching improved, the ERA ballooned to 4.54. The Brewers decided to trade Strzelecki for Andrew Chafin—a trade that ultimately didn’t benefit either side. Strzelecki only managed one game for the Diamondbacks before being DFA-rejected. Cleveland gave him another chance, and he didn’t disappoint in 10 appearances in 2024. But that was also Strzelecki’s last time in MLB.
The following months were a series of ups and downs: Pirates, Triple-A 9.90 ERA, released. Rays, injured, then released. 2025 passed in silence. And for many, the story should have ended there.
But the Brewers didn’t see “a failed pitcher.” They saw something they had once unlocked.
Strzelecki has a low arm slot, around 20 degrees, creating an unusual horizontal angle for sweeper and changeup — the two pitches were once more than 31 inches apart in horizontal break. His 92 mph fastball didn’t intimidate hitters, but it certainly did. When everything clicked, Strzelecki didn’t need overpower. He just needed to mislead opponents.
That’s why the Brewers brought him back. Not because of certainty. But because of his potential.
The reality is the road ahead is narrow. Milwaukee’s pitching staff is crowded. Strzelecki is 31. His contract isn’t guaranteed. A minor injury, a lackluster spring training, and the door could close forever.
But baseball rarely operates on dry logic. It operates on moment, on the right person at the right time. And the Brewers understand this better than anyone: the bullpen always needs a player. Injuries are inevitable. A reliever who has a knack for surviving in MLB is always more valuable than someone who’s never been tested in the ring.
Spring Training won’t be where Strzelecki “reclaims his glory.” It’s where he has to prove he still exists. And for the Brewers, it’s a small gamble—but if they win, it could provide more than just a backup arm.
Sometimes, teams don’t sign players.
They sign the belief that history can repeat itself—at least, one more time.
Leave a Reply