The New York Mets didnât just tweak their roster this offseason.

They tore it apart and rebuilt it like a franchise that finally decided comfort was the enemy.
After losing Pete Alonso and Edwin DĂaz in free agency, the Mets kept pulling on the thread â trading away Brandon Nimmo, Jeff McNeil, and Jesse Winker, among others, in a sweeping reset that made one thing clear:
This isnât the same Mets team walking into 2026.
And with all that chaos came the move that might define their season more than any other â the decision to bolster the rotation by trading for former Milwaukee Brewers ace Freddy Peralta.
Itâs the kind of acquisition that instantly raises the stakes. Not just because Peralta is talented, but because he represents something the Mets have been chasing for years: stability at the top of the rotation.
But thereâs a catch.
Peralta is arriving on an expiring contract.
And that means his first season in New York might also be his last â unless the Mets decide they canât afford to let him go.
A reunion that feels⊠intentional

Peraltaâs move to Queens isnât just a baseball transaction. Itâs a reunion.
The 29-year-old right-hander is now back under the umbrella of David Stearns, the Metsâ president of baseball operations â the same executive who helped bring Peralta into the Brewers organization back in 2015.
That history matters. It creates trust. It creates familiarity. And it makes the trade feel less like a gamble and more like a calculated bet on a player Stearns knows deeply.
Peralta even admitted he wasnât shocked by the rumors.
He said he âhad a feelingâ he would end up with the Mets as his name started circulating in trade talks â a line that sounds casual, but also suggests something else: this wasnât random. This was a plan.
The contract situation is the real pressure point

For 2026, Peralta is set to make $8 million â an extremely reasonable number for a two-time All-Star starter in todayâs market.
But itâs also the kind of number that screams one thing:
Bargain.
And bargains donât last long.
Because if Peralta performs in New York the way he performed in Milwaukee, his price changes instantly. Not next winter â immediately.
The Mets wouldnât just be paying for a pitcher. Theyâd be paying for leverage, scarcity, and the reality that good starting pitching is the most expensive thing in baseball when youâre trying to win.
Thatâs why extension rumors started the moment he arrived.
Peraltaâs comments sound calm⊠but theyâre not nothing

Peralta spoke with The Athleticâs Tim Britton about the possibility of signing a long-term extension with the Mets. His answer wasnât a yes. It wasnât a no.
It was the kind of quote that keeps every door open:
âI just got here,â Peralta said. âIâve got to see around and share time with my teammates, think about different ideas, learn about everybody â the coaches and the organization in general. And then we can see.â
On the surface, itâs a standard response. A player being respectful, not rushing anything, taking time to settle in.
But Mets fans know how this works.
When a player shuts down extension talk, you can feel it. The language is colder. The answer is sharper. Peralta didnât do that.
Instead, he left space.
And in baseball, space is where negotiations live.
Why the Mets might need him to stay

Peralta is stepping into a Mets rotation that includes Sean Manaea, David Peterson, Nolan McLean, and others â a group with talent, but also plenty of uncertainty depending on health, performance, and how the season unfolds.
If the Mets are serious about contending in 2026 â not just âcompeting,â but actually threatening the leagueâs top teams â they need dependable innings. They need a starter who can take the ball every fifth day and keep the team out of panic mode.
Thatâs what Peralta represents.
And after losing Alonso and DĂaz, the Mets are already feeling the consequences of letting key names walk. Theyâve chosen a new direction â one built around retooling, flexibility, and making uncomfortable decisions.
But if Peralta becomes the anchor of the rotation, letting him leave after one year would feel like another self-inflicted wound.
The extension question will get louder fast

Right now, itâs January. Peralta is new. Everything is polite.
But once spring training starts, the questions sharpen. Once he starts pitching in meaningful games, the timeline compresses.
And if he starts strong, the entire conversation flips from âshould the Mets extend him?â to âhow fast do the Mets need to act before it becomes too late?â
Because an $8 million ace on an expiring deal isnât just valuable.
Itâs a ticking clock.
Freddy Peralta says he needs time to learn the organization.
The Mets might not have that luxury.
And as 2026 approaches, the real question isnât whether an extension is possibleâŠ
Itâs whether New York can afford to let this be temporary. âĄ
Leave a Reply