The Milwaukee Brewers entered the offseason in a position most teams could only dream of: the best-performing MLB team of the previous season. But just a few months later, the atmosphere around them has changed dramatically. While the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Mets are relentlessly strengthening their rosters to aim for the World Series, the Brewers are looking… more cautious than ever.
The trade of Freddy Peralta to the Mets was a clear turning point. In the long term, it might have been a sensible deal: Peralta was a rental, the Brewers gained two promising prospects and avoided a total loss. But currently, it has weakened the roster — and the Brewers haven’t made any major moves to compensate.
Instead of a splash in the market, Milwaukee just signed Reese McGuire on a minor league contract — a small, almost quiet, signing.
It’s no coincidence that the fan reaction has been rather subdued.
McGuire is a veteran catcher, having played for the Blue Jays, White Sox, Red Sox, and most recently the Cubs. He’s not an unfamiliar name, nor is he a prospect. He’s the kind of player who knows what he’s doing, someone who can step into the lineup when needed and won’t disrupt the team’s structure.
Last season with the Cubs, McGuire shot .226/.245/.444 in 44 games. Low OBP, decent power, but overall his batting average is around the average for a backup catcher. His greater strength lies in defense — solid framing, good pitcher handling, and not disruptive.
With the Brewers, the scenario is clear: McGuire will start in the minor leagues, but has a real chance to become a backup catcher if things go right. In a team that already has a reliable primary catcher, that’s a perfectly logical role.
However, the bigger picture is what’s really worth considering.
This isn’t a “game-changing” signing. It doesn’t replace Peralta. It doesn’t close the gap with the Dodgers or Mets. It just adds depth—a safe, familiar, typical Brewers move.
And that’s what makes it controversial.
Milwaukee has built a reputation as a well-developed, cost-effective, and competitive team. But after years of playoff appearances without reaching the World Series, the question is growing: are they getting too complacent with being “good enough”?
Reese McGuire is a useful player. No one denies that. As a backup catcher, he brings stability and experience. But with the team having just sold their ace, the next step being a minor league signing feels… disappointing to many.
Perhaps the Brewers aren’t done yet. Perhaps this is just one small step in a series of other moves. But so far, the message being sent out is pretty clear: Milwaukee is prioritizing defense over offense.
And in a National League where the big teams are constantly accelerating, that caution could become a disadvantage.
Leave a Reply