Manchester City have said goodbye to icons before. But this one feels different.
In recent years, the Etihad has witnessed the calculated departure of club greats. Kevin De Bruyne moved on at the end of his contract amid fitness concerns and questions over value for money. Kyle Walker’s influence waned. Ilkay Gündogan’s physical edge faded. Even stalwarts like Manuel Akanji, John Stones and Nathan Aké have faced quiet scrutiny as the squad evolves.
Timing, in those cases, felt logical.
But Bernardo Silva?
This feels premature.
The Portuguese international, now 31 and approaching the end of his contract this summer, continues to demonstrate why he remains central to Pep Guardiola’s system. If anything, he looks more indispensable than ever.
Week after week, Silva operates as the tactical glue holding City together. His intelligence, relentless pressing and positional awareness allow Guardiola’s complex structure to function seamlessly. He may not dominate headlines with towering goal tallies, but his fingerprints are all over City’s biggest moments.
Take the recent 2-1 win at Liverpool. Or Saturday’s gritty 2-1 victory over Newcastle. In both matches, Silva’s influence stretched far beyond the stat sheet. He pressed from the front, dropped into midfield when needed, and dictated tempo with the calm of a player who understands every inch of Guardiola’s blueprint.
In a title race where Arsenal are pushing relentlessly, those intangibles matter.
Silva’s leadership has grown, too. Now club captain, he sets the emotional tone. When matches tighten and pressure mounts, he doesn’t drift — he demands more. At times, he has even led the press himself, charging defenders and forcing errors through sheer will.
City are undergoing a subtle rebuild. Younger faces are emerging. Roles are shifting. But transitions require continuity — players who embody the culture and standards Guardiola has embedded over nearly a decade.
Silva is that bridge.
Letting him walk away this summer, purely based on age or wage structure, risks destabilising that balance. Unlike others whose physical levels dipped noticeably, Silva’s engine still burns fiercely. His adaptability allows him to operate centrally, wide, deep or advanced. Few players offer that tactical elasticity.
There’s also a broader implication.
With ongoing speculation around Guardiola’s own future, keeping experienced lieutenants like Silva could prove pivotal. Continuity on the pitch may influence continuity in the dugout. Stability breeds stability.
City sit five points behind Arsenal with a game in hand. The margins are razor thin. In these moments, you don’t discard experience lightly.
Moving on from legends can be necessary.
But moving on from Bernardo Silva right now?
That feels like solving a problem that doesn’t exist.
Leave a Reply