The Los Angeles Dodgers have spent the last two seasons reminding the baseball world what dominance looks like. Back-to-back World Series titles. A roster stacked with stars. And an offseason that didnât just maintain the machine â it upgraded it.

Oct 20, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (27) and designated hitter George Springer (4) celebrate after winning game seven of the ALCS round for the 2025 MLB playoffs against the Seattle Mariners at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images | Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images
Kyle Tucker. Edwin DĂaz. Two of the biggest names available, both landing in Los Angeles like the leagueâs worst nightmare becoming reality.
So when MLB Network recently asked the question, âWho could realistically threaten the Dodgers in 2026?â it wasnât just a debate segment.
It was a pulse check. A search for the one team that might actually have the nerve â and the firepower â to end the dynasty before it becomes something even bigger.
And the answer that came out felt almost⊠uncomfortable.
Because Sean Casey didnât hesitate.
In his eyes, the Toronto Blue Jays should be viewed as the top threat to dethrone the Dodgers in 2026 â even above the Yankees, Mets, Phillies, and Mariners.
At first glance, it sounds bold. Even dramatic. The Dodgers just got stronger, and Toronto didnât even land Tucker.
They also lost Bo Bichette to the New York Mets. On paper, those are the kinds of losses that usually create a gap.
But Caseyâs reasoning cuts deeper than headlines.

He pointed to something that fans donât always want to admit out loud: Toronto matched up with the Dodgers incredibly well in the World Series â and statistically, they may have been the better team.
They just didnât finish the job.
And thatâs where the story starts to shift.
Because when a team comes that close â inches from winning it all â it doesnât always break them. Sometimes it hardens them.
Sometimes it creates the kind of quiet obsession that doesnât show up in press conferences⊠but shows up in the way a roster gets built.
Toronto didnât âreload.â They sharpened.

The Blue Jays didnât have a flashy offseason built around one massive superstar signing. Instead, they built something that looks far more dangerous in October: depth, flexibility, and pitching options that donât run out after the third inning.
Casey specifically highlighted how much he liked Torontoâs additions:
- Dylan Cease, a frontline arm who can change a postseason series by himself
- Kazuma Okamoto, a move that adds a different kind of offensive presence
- Cody Ponce, a wild card pickup from Korea who brings intrigue and upside
- Tyler Rogers, a bullpen piece with a style that can disrupt timing at the highest level
And then thereâs the name that keeps hovering like a shadow over Torontoâs entire 2026 outlook:
Anthony Santander.
In 2025, he was practically a non-factor due to health issues. But insiders are increasingly aligned on one belief: if Santander stays healthy, Torontoâs lineup changes shape. Not just slightly â dramatically.
Because suddenly the Blue Jays arenât just âa good team.â They become the kind of team where you look up in the sixth inning and realize there are no easy outs.
The quiet advantage Toronto has that nobody wants to say

The Dodgers are built to overpower you. Toronto might be built to outlast you.
Last year, the Blue Jays proved something in the postseason that teams only learn the hard way: bench depth wins games when stars go cold.
And heading into 2026, that depth looks even more stable. There likely wonât be as many chaotic roster battles as there were in 2025. Instead, the bigger storyline might be something more subtle â and more lethal:
Toronto can mix and match lineups based on matchups without weakening itself.
Thatâs not just strategy. Thatâs control.
The pitching situation is almost âtoo goodâ â and thatâs the point

If thereâs one thing Toronto has now that most teams donât, itâs this:
They have more starting pitching than they can comfortably fit.
Kevin Gausman. Dylan Cease. Shane Bieber. Trey Yesavage. JosĂ© BerrĂos. Cody Ponce. Eric Lauer. Even Bowden Francis working back from injury.
Thatâs not just a rotation. Thatâs a Đ·Đ°ĐżĐ°Ń of arms you can survive a full season with â and still have something left when October starts draining teams dry.
And thatâs the part that makes Toronto feel different in 2026.
The Dodgers may still be the final boss. They may still be the âteam to beat.â
But the Blue Jays? They donât feel like underdogs anymore.

They feel like the team that already knows what it takes to stand on that stageâŠ
and what it feels like to walk away without the ring.
The scariest teams arenât always the ones who look unbeatable.
Sometimes itâs the team that got embarrassed by one playâŠ
and came back looking like theyâre not planning to let anyone breathe this time.
So the question isnât whether Toronto can threaten the Dodgers.
Itâs whether the Dodgers are ready for a Blue Jays team that no longer looks surprised to be hereâŠ
and doesnât look interested in âalmostâ ever again.
Leave a Reply