Bo Bichette’s departure elicited a common reaction from many in Toronto: anxiety. A long-serving shortstop, a consistent batsman, a familiar face. When he signed with the New York Mets, the Blue Jays were forced to pivot—and at first glance, it seemed like a step backward.
But a closer look reveals a subtle shift Toronto had been avoiding for too long.
The Blue Jays aren’t simply patching things up with another star. They’re restructuring. Andrés Giménez is given the key to daily shortstop, Ernie Clement holds second base, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. mans first base, and Alejandro Kirk is behind the plate. And with the signing of Kazuma Okamoto for third base, Toronto isn’t trying to “replace Bichette,” but rather rewriting the role of the entire infield.
The most noteworthy aspect isn’t the ops or home run.
It’s the defense.
Giménez is a controversial batsman, but an almost undisputed defender. Three consecutive Gold Glove wins, 11 outs above average, top 97th percentile according to Statcast. The interceptions he makes aren’t just outs — they’re inning savers. And when you put him alongside Ernie Clement, who had 15 OAAs last season, the Blue Jays have a middle infield capable of shutting down any ground ball in the most crucial area of ​​the court.
The contrast with Bichette is clear, though no one wants to say it outright. Bichette is still a quality hitter, but defensively, he used to be among the lowest-ranked players on the Toronto roster. Losing him certainly makes the lineup less appealing. But at the same time, it frees the Blue Jays from a weakness they’ve become accustomed to.
Guerrero Jr. — a Gold Glove winner — completes that picture at first base. The only question remaining is Okamoto. The Japanese batter was brought in for his offensive ability, but his defense remains questionable. Toronto knows that. They’ve also prepared an Addison Barger option if needed. But if Okamoto can keep his hot bat, the pressure to change won’t come immediately.
Why is defense so important in Toronto?
The answer lies in the mound.
Chris Bassitt, Kevin Gausman, José BerrÃos—all are in the top 40 MLB for induced ground balls. Tyler Rogers, the bullpen rookie, has a ground-ball rate in the top 6 of the league. This is a staff that thrives on getting the ball on the ground. And nothing is worse for such a pitching staff than a shaky defense behind them.
The Blue Jays are doing the opposite.
They’re not chasing flashy bats. They’re building a system that makes the pitcher’s job easier, with shorter innings and a lower pitch count. It’s the kind of change that rarely makes headlines, but accumulates advantages over time.
Mike Petriello once pointed out a cold reality: the top 5 defensive teams according to Statcast all make the playoffs. Of the 9 worst defensive teams, only one survives. Defense doesn’t create highlights every night, but it lays the groundwork for September.
The Blue Jays may not score as many runs as before. But they can prevent opponents from scoring fewer. And in an increasingly tough AL, shifting from “winning by explosive” to “winning by control” could be the turning point Toronto needs.
Bo Bichette is gone. But perhaps, at the same time, the Blue Jays have also left a version of themselves — a more vulnerable version they once admitted to.
Leave a Reply