The Cleveland Guardians like to say they trust pitching.
They build around it. They protect it. They invest in it with patience that few organizations can match. And heading into 2026, that philosophy is being tested quietly — not by a lack of arms, but by a single unresolved question.
What exactly is Joey Cantillo?
On paper, the Guardians appear stable. All six starters who cycled through the rotation late in 2025 are expected back: Tanner Bibee, Gavin Williams, Parker Messick, Logan Allen, Slade Cecconi — and Cantillo. It looks like continuity. It feels like confidence.
But not all continuity carries the same weight.
Cantillo enters 2026 with more eyes on him than any other starter in the group, not because of hype, but because of uncertainty. Over the past two seasons, he’s been everything Cleveland needed him to be — and everything they weren’t sure he could be — sometimes within the same month.
He has moved between roles, from reliever to starter and back again, searching for consistency while the organization searched for clarity. In 43 appearances, 21 of them starts, the results have flashed promise but never settled into comfort.
The Guardians optioned him to the minors three separate times in 2025, a decision that spoke less about punishment and more about hesitation.
And then, just as the team was making its stunning 15.5-game comeback to win the American League Central, Cantillo was watching from Columbus.
That could have been the end of the story.
Instead, it became the pivot.
When Cantillo returned to Cleveland less than a month later, he didn’t arrive quietly. He delivered. An 8–1 win over Boston. Seven strikeouts. One run. Six steady innings.
Days later, a season-best eight shutout innings against Kansas City. No drama. No excuses. Just command.
Over his final three starts — all wins — Cantillo allowed just four runs on 11 hits, striking out 16. More importantly, hitters looked uncomfortable.
They chased. They froze. His strike metrics told a story his early-season stat lines never could.
Even the velocity changed the conversation. His season average sat at 91.7 mph, but over his final stretch, he was touching 93 consistently. Not a massive jump — but a meaningful one. Enough to suggest growth rather than survival.
Across two major league seasons, Cantillo owns a 3.69 ERA, a 1.269 WHIP, and over 10 strikeouts per nine innings. Those numbers don’t scream ace. They whisper something else: potential that hasn’t been fully trusted yet.
Former MLB general manager Steve Phillips put words to that quiet intrigue. “The guy I like is Joey Cantillo,” Phillips said. “He’s an intriguing guy for me… I’m encouraged to see what he can do this year.”
Encouraged is the right word.
Not convinced. Not certain.
Encouraged.
That distinction matters heading into spring training. Cleveland’s bullpen has been rebuilt with raw arms and second chances. Early-season reliability will fall on the starters, and patience may be thinner than it appears. Cantillo is likely to get the ball again — but this time, the margin for wobble feels smaller.
He doesn’t need to dominate. He doesn’t need to reinvent himself.
But he does need to answer the question that’s followed him for two years: can he be trusted every fifth day?
Spring training will offer the first hint. The Guardians open February 21 against Cincinnati, and Cantillo’s opportunity begins there — not as a breakout candidate, but as a pitcher standing at the edge of definition.
Because in Cleveland, belief is earned quietly.
And in 2026, Joey Cantillo may finally find out whether the Guardians are ready to stop hesitating — or whether hesitation has already told the story.
Leave a Reply