On Fox News’ The Five, Jessica Tarlov and Jeanine Pirro are known for their fiery debates, often clashing over political issues with the intensity expected from a liberal political strategist and a conservative former judge. Their on-air exchanges, marked by sharp disagreements and occasional personal barbs, might suggest a relationship fraught with tension. However, behind the scenes, Tarlov and Pirro share a surprising friendship that defies their ideological differences, offering a glimpse into how mutual respect and shared roots can bridge divides.
On-Air Rivals: A Clash of Perspectives
As co-hosts on The Five, Tarlov and Pirro frequently find themselves on opposite sides of the political spectrum. Tarlov, a Democratic commentator with a background in political consulting, brings a progressive viewpoint, while Pirro, a former prosecutor and judge, champions conservative ideals with unwavering conviction. Their debates often escalate, drawing attention from viewers and media alike. For instance, on September 10, 2024, the two engaged in a heated exchange over whether President Donald Trump was “selfish.” Pirro accused Tarlov of harboring a general disdain for Republicans, prompting Tarlov to retort with critiques of Trump’s behavior. Another notable clash occurred on April 15, 2025, during a discussion about immigration and Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s detention, where reports—possibly exaggerated—claimed Tarlov was escorted off the set after a particularly intense argument.
These moments are not isolated. Topics like abortion rights, deportation policies, and high-profile legal cases, such as the Loudoun County sexual assault controversy, have sparked interruptions and accusations of derailing discussions. The dynamic is fueled by their contrasting styles: Tarlov’s data-driven arguments meet Pirro’s passionate, no-nonsense delivery, creating a combustible mix that makes for compelling television. Yet, these exchanges, while intense, typically remain within the bounds of professional discourse, showcasing their ability to challenge each other without letting disagreements fester into personal animosity.
Off-Screen Friends: Finding Common Ground
Despite their on-air rivalry, Tarlov and Pirro have cultivated an unexpected friendship off-camera. In an interview on Liz Claman’s podcast Everyone Talks To Liz Claman, Pirro revealed the roots of their bond, stating, “We found common ground, and then from that common ground, we became friends.” This connection stems partly from their shared New York background, which has provided a foundation for mutual understanding. Tarlov, in turn, has acknowledged their ability to connect over shared experiences, highlighting how these moments have fostered a genuine rapport.
This off-screen friendship is a testament to their ability to separate professional disagreements from personal interactions. Described as “bipartisan besties” in some media coverage, Tarlov and Pirro demonstrate that ideological differences need not preclude respect or camaraderie. Their ability to discuss issues civilly outside the studio suggests a level of maturity and professionalism that contrasts sharply with the polarized rhetoric often seen on television.
Leave a Reply