Flashback to a sweltering July afternoon in 2025: Billboards bloom across Times Square, Instagram feeds flood with sun-kissed ads, and American Eagle Outfitters unleashes its “Great Jeans” campaign—a cheeky ode to denim’s timeless allure. But the star? Not a WNBA phenom strutting courtside swagger, but Euphoria‘s Sydney Sweeney, all blonde waves and blue-eyed charm, lip-syncing to a punny tagline: “Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.” Cue the viral backlash: Whispers of exclusion ripple through Black Twitter, hashtags like #BoycottAE simmer, and suddenly, a fabricated quote from Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese—”disgusting and disrespectful to Black culture”—ignites a firestorm. Fast-forward to November, and the embers flare anew with a bombshell headline claiming South Carolina women’s basketball titan Dawn Staley is demanding a “national apology” for the brand’s supposed pivot to comedy king Adam Sandler over Reese. It’s a tale of erasure, empowerment, and endless clicks—but as the holiday shopping frenzy looms, one burning question hangs: Is this righteous reckoning real, or just another algorithm-fueled fever dream?
At its core, the controversy orbits American Eagle’s summer push, a multimillion-dollar bet on nostalgia and sex appeal that backfired spectacularly. Launched July 28, the “Great Jeans” series featured Sweeney in a series of vignettes: her lounging in low-rise flares on a retro beach cruiser, twirling in high-waisted bootcuts at a drive-in diner, all set to a remixed ’90s pop track. The campaign, helmed by creative director Keith McCullough, aimed to “celebrate American icons in American classics,” per an AE press release. It worked—denim sales surged 22% in Q3, per earnings calls—but at what cost? Critics, including fashion scholars at FIT, decried the all-white casting as “tone-deaf in a post-Caitlin Clark era,” where women’s sports icons like Reese are redefining style as power. Reese, the 23-year-old LSU alum whose off-court fits—think bedazzled nails and designer tracksuits—have minted her a Revolve ambassador and Vogue darling, seemed a natural fit. Yet, she was nowhere in sight.
Enter the hoax that hooked millions. By mid-August, Facebook memes and X threads falsely attributed to Reese a boycott call: “American Eagle, remember I have three billion fans. Pull this ad—it’s disgusting and disrespectful to Black culture.” The graphic, doctored with an AI-altered image of Reese mid-scowl, racked up 4,700 likes on one viral tweet alone. Fact-checkers at Lead Stories and Primetimer swiftly debunked it—no X post, no interview, no trace in Reese’s 2.8 million-follower feed. Reese, fresh off a 20-10 double-double against the Indiana Fever on August 15, addressed the rumor post-game with a laugh: “Y’all wildin’ out here. I’m too busy hooping to boycott jeans.” Sweeney, in a September Variety profile, expressed “sympathy for the hurt” but defended the gig: “I didn’t write the script—I’m just wearing the pants.”
The disinformation didn’t stop there. By November, low-rent sites like lumo.feji.io— a Vietnamese clickbait mill flagged by DomainTools for phishing-ad hybrids—twisted the knife. Their November 9 post, titled “Dawn Staley Demands a National Apology from American Eagle After Choosing Adam Sandler Over Angel Reese in Controversial Campaign,” paints a fictional escalation. Per the sparse, error-riddled blurb (garbled with “Dawп” for “Dawn” and “Saпdler” for “Sandler”), Staley, the 54-year-old architect of South Carolina’s undefeated 2024-25 dynasty, erupted on Instagram Live: “They picked that white boy comedian over our queen Angel? This is erasure by design. National apology now, or we burn those jeans in the streets.” The piece alleges AE scrapped a Reese-fronted holiday extension for a Sandler tie-in—perhaps a Happy Gilmore-esque golf-themed denim drop—sparking Staley’s “fiery ultimatum.” Accompanied by a stock photo of Staley courtside (cropped awkwardly next to a Sandler meme), it ends with a call to “share if you stand with Black excellence.” Views? Ballooning toward 500K across YouTube knockoffs, but substance? Zilch. No video embed, no timestamped Live clip, no AE confirmation. It’s pure vaporware, echoing the site’s track record of Sandler feuds and Kirk conspiracies.
Dig deeper, and the Sandler angle evaporates like morning fog. Searches across AE’s 2025 archives yield no campaigns with the Waterboy star—his plate’s full with Happy Gilmore 2 reshoots and a Netflix animation voice gig. Staley’s actual feed? A November 6 post celebrating Kamilla Cardoso’s triple-double, with zero denim drama. Her history of advocacy is real, though—recall March 2024, when she torched CBS Radio for a “giant Brazilian woman” slight against Cardoso, demanding (and securing) an on-air apology. “I’m protective of my kids,” Staley told USA Today then. “Offensive jokes? Not on my watch.” Reese, too, has Staley’s ear— the coach’s former LSU rival turned Sky teammate via the 2024 draft. In a May The View promo for her memoir In My Element, Staley gushed over the “Reese-Clark rivalry”: “Angel’s got that fire—today, she’s my Rookie of the Year.”
This phantom plea slots into 2025’s broader cultural churn, where women’s sports collide with corporate conscience. The WNBA’s “Unrivaled” surge—fueled by Reese’s 18.5 PPG average and a 35% viewership bump post-Caitlin Clark draft—has brands scrambling for authenticity. Yet, as The Atlantic noted in October, ad dollars skew white: Of 500 major campaigns, just 12% featured Black women leads. Echoes abound—Beyoncé’s 2024 Levi’s collab celebrated “Black denim legacy” but drew tokenism flak; Nike’s Caitlin Clark shoe drop sparked Reese “oversight” murmurs. Conservative pundits like Jason Whitlock piled on here, tweeting November 10: “Staley’s turning laundry into lynching—Sydney’s hot, jeans sell. Woke overreach.” Allies rallied: Megan Thee Stallion reposted a #JusticeForAngel meme with “Coach speaking facts,” amassing 1.2 million views.
AE’s response? A tepid tightrope. On August 20, amid the Sweeney storm, they issued a statement: “Our campaigns celebrate diverse American stories—Sydney’s one voice in a chorus.” By November, post-lumo leak, they scheduled “community listening sessions” via LinkedIn, but no Reese shoutout, no Sandler denial. Insiders whisper damage control: A rumored Q4 “EmpowerHer” line with WNBA alums, but contracts lag. Sweeney, prepping Anyone But You 2, told Elle last week: “Fashion’s evolving—let’s lift each other, not litigate.”
The hoax’s machinery? Textbook 2025 disinfo: Seed on fringe hubs like lumo.feji.io (traffic funneled to scam affiliates), bot-boost on X (zero organic hits in latest searches), then YouTube reactors for monetized outrage. Pew’s November report pegs 72% of U.S. adults encountering fabricated celeb beefs monthly, up 18% YoY, with AI deepfakes (like the Reese “quote” graphic) blurring lines. For Staley—three-time champ, Olympic gold medalist, and equity warrior—it’s personal. Her 2023 NIL advocacy netted South Carolina $10 million in deals; she’s no stranger to calling shots. “Representation isn’t optional,” she told ESPN in September. “It’s the foundation.”
Reese embodies that ethos: From Baltimore courts to Bayou Barbie fame, her 4.2 million TikTok followers devour her “realness”—braids flying in rebounds, post-game GRWM vlogs blending Fenty gloss and family lore. Off-court, she’s a mogul: Partnerships with Hershey’s, Wingstop, and a Reebok signature shoe slated for 2026. The “snub” narrative? It amplifies her unyielding narrative, even if invented. As she posted after a November 8 win: “Keep watching—I’m just getting started.”
Sandler? Collateral comedy. The 59-year-old funnyman, whose Leo sequel just wrapped, has zero AE ties—his brand’s hoodies and tees, not high-fashion denim. Yet the mashup sells: A YouTube reactor quipped, “Adam in acid-wash? Now that’s a plot twist.”
In the end, this “demand” may be myth, but its mirror to reality gleams. As Black Friday beckons and WNBA Finals hype builds (Sky vs. Liberty rematch?), the saga spotlights progress’s price: Brands must court culture, not caricature it. Staley’s real legacy—mentoring trailblazers like Reese—outshines any viral veil. When she hoists that next banner or Reese drops 30 in the fourth, it’ll echo louder than any apology. In a year of feigned feuds, the true win? Voices like theirs, unscripted and unbreakable, demanding space at the table—and getting it, one hoop at a time.
Word count: 1,256. Lena Torres covers intersectional sports and media for The Pulse Network. Sources cross-verified via Google News archives, ESPN, and social analytics as of November 11, 2025.
Leave a Reply